PRACTICAL GUIDE

From audio to MIDI: listen, transpose and edit in your DAW

A practical audio-to-MIDI workflow: compare by ear, edit notes in MIDI workshop and prepare the file for your DAW.

On this page8 sections

Audio and MIDI: what changes

Audio contains recorded sound. MIDI contains note instructions: pitch, start, duration and other events. Transcription produces an editable proposal, not a copy of the voice, lyrics or original timbre. Use it to recover a melody, try another key or prepare material for your DAW.

1. Prepare a clear excerpt

Start with 10–30 seconds of an isolated voice or instrument, without drums or accompaniment. This is a practical starting point, not the tool’s limit. The transcriber accepts up to ten minutes and 128 MB, but analysis time depends on your device. A full song with several instruments is harder to interpret.

Trim silence with the audio trimmer. The vocal separator has separate access conditions and limits; separation artifacts can affect detection. Use your own or authorized material.

2. Transcribe and compare by ear

Open the audio-to-MIDI transcriber, load the excerpt and listen to the original before starting analysis. Afterwards, compare the original with MIDI playback. The model downloads for processing on your device; your file is not sent for transcription.

Under Playback sound in the transcriber, choose Grand piano or Classical guitar, for example. The selected sound is not embedded in the MIDI: choose an instrument in your music software when you open the file.

MIDI playback uses recorded reference instruments. Judge notes and their timing rather than similarity to the recorded instrument. If extra notes or incorrect gaps appear, try a cleaner, shorter excerpt. Automatic transcription requires review.

After transcription, the result panel brings together MIDI playback, a plot of all detected notes and download. The original has its own controls; starting either playback stops the other. Position only moves playback and does not trim the download. If you change tempo or meter, MIDI playback and download remain disabled until you apply those settings.

Transcription distinguishes audio preparation, note detection and MIDI preparation. The percentage refers to detection when reported by the model; other stages do not show an invented remaining time. Cancel is beside progress. Detection settings let you change sensitivity, discard notes shorter than a minimum or restrict pitches. They apply when you transcribe again; the result identifies the settings that produced it. Conservative can miss quiet notes and Sensitive can add extra ones. Filters can also discard correct notes; Reset detection restores Balanced with no additional filters. These controls do not separate instruments or extract drums.

Practical example: a four-note phrase

Record or play your own C–D–E–G phrase, followed by a pause. Transcribe it and check that playback contains four notes in that order. If a note appears an octave too high, correct its pitch in MIDI workshop. If E is split into two notes, check its attack and duration before joining them. These illustrate possible errors; they are not guaranteed results or a model accuracy test.

Correct one octave, keep the rhythmThe first note changes from C5 (72) to C4 (60). The other notes and all start times stay the same.

Before editing

C5, D4, E4 and G4C5G4E4D4C41234Quarter-note beats

After editing

C4, D4, E4 and G4C5G4E4D4C41234Quarter-note beats

Illustrative manual edit, not a guaranteed transcription result. HertzKit uses C4 for MIDI note 60; octave labels may differ in other software.

3. Inspect the MIDI in the viewer

Download the result and open it in the MIDI viewer. Select a track and check pitches, starts and durations. The viewer does not edit notes. MIDI workshop lets you inspect events and edit each existing note’s pitch, velocity, start and end, as well as apply repairs or quantization. Open Edit notes in the original, make one change, then Prepare version. Compare Original and Prepared version before downloading.

4. Try a different key

Load the file in the MIDI transposer, select a semitone shift and listen before downloading. +2 raises notes by a whole tone; −12 lowers them by an octave. This shifts notes; it does not automatically detect or correct the key of a transcription.

5. Correct and save in your DAW

Import the MIDI alongside the original audio and check extra notes, octave errors, starts and durations. Use the DAW to add, delete or join notes and finish the arrangement; check the edits you prepared in Workshop with the intended instrument. Quantize only for a musical reason. Then open MIDI to score, choose meter, key signature and grid, and download MusicXML for a notation editor. Do not expect MIDI to contain all those notation decisions already.

120 BPM and 4/4 are starting values, not detections. Set a reference tempo and meter, then press Apply tempo and meter before downloading. The tool recalculates ticks to preserve audio timing with one-tick rounding: choosing another BPM here does not speed up or slow down the phrase. Change the DAW playback tempo afterwards to alter its duration. HertzKit’s result uses fixed pitches and includes no pitch-bend curves.

When the result does not match

  • Extra notes: avoid full mixes, heavy reverberation and noise.
  • Different timbre: this is expected; MIDI does not preserve the recorded sound.
  • Correct notes but shifted rhythm in your DAW: check tempo import and file placement.
  • Slow analysis: try a short excerpt and close other demanding tasks.

Basic Pitch supports polyphony, but its documentation recommends one instrument at a time. See the model documentation and HertzKit credits.