PRACTICAL GUIDE
Why MIDI sounds different between players
Notes, instruments, sustain and pitch bend: understand what MIDI preserves and why a preview is not the sound of your project.
On this page8 sections
The file contains instructions
A MIDI file describes events: play a note, release it, change a program or move a controller. It does not contain a recording of that instrument. Sending the same notes to a piano and a synthesizer keeps the sequence but changes the sound. To share exactly how the project sounds, export audio too.
Velocity is not a fader
Two notes at velocity 80 may sound different in different libraries. Some instruments change samples with velocity; others open a filter or alter the attack. Editing velocity can refine a performance but does not guarantee mix balance. Listen through the final instrument before approving it.
Sustain and note duration are different
A note-off and the end of a sound are different. With CC64 active, a compatible instrument can sustain a note after key release. Releasing the pedal releases notes held by that control; a key still pressed can keep sounding. The viewer and MIDI workshop interpret sustain for playback, but do not reproduce every resonance or piano function.
Pitch bend needs a range
Pitch bend shifts tuning relative to a note and acts on its channel. HertzKit reference playback uses the RPN 0,0 range, or ±2 semitones if absent. A DAW instrument expecting another range can reproduce the curve differently. The transposer and workshop preserve these messages in their event exports; check the destination instrument. This does not apply to the fixed-pitch audio-to-MIDI draft or the score’s quantized MIDI.
Tempo, meter and channel
Ticks acquire duration through the file division and tempo events. Meter organizes reading; it does not itself change event duration. MIDI channel 10 commonly holds percussion: transposing its note numbers can change drum instruments. The transposer keeps channel 10 notes unchanged; Workshop excludes them by default unless you enable “Include percussion”.
What to expect from HertzKit playback
HertzKit uses recorded grand piano, classical guitar, upright bass and percussion for musical playback, with up to 48 simultaneous voices. MIDI instruments follows the supported program families; other families play as piano. Solo presets omit the original percussion. Sustain and pitch bend are supported, but not every expression controller, SysEx message or original sound bank. Use it to check notes, entries and durations; check the final timbre and articulation in your project.
Compare one track with two sounds
- Open the MIDI viewer and choose Load example.
- Under Track, choose Melody. Select Grand piano and press Play.
- Stop, choose Classical guitar and play again. The notes and timing stay the same; the attack and decay change.
Practice backing adds a pulse or simple drums only to this playback. It is not part of your MIDI file.
A delivery that avoids confusion
Share MIDI with reference audio, intended tempo and meter, track names and a note about instruments. If the project changes tempo, tell the recipient to import that map. Everyone can then understand the idea without needing your player.