PRACTICAL GUIDE

How to humanize a programmed track

A programmed part can be expressive or deliberately exact. Decide what to change in timing, accents and articulation before adding variation.

On this page7 sections

Compare accents and placement without moving the beat

Four bars of recorded drums at 96 BPM. The kick keeps its positions; the second version changes hi-hat accents and shifts selected hits.

Choose a version to play.

First listen: follow the kick in both versions, then focus on the hi-hat. Does B organise the motion better, or do you prefer A’s regularity? An exact programmed part can be the right choice. The task is to recognise decisions rather than guess whether a human played.

Try one variable: download both MIDI files and open them in your DAW with the same drum kit. In a copy of B, return the hits to the grid while keeping their velocities. Compare it with B to isolate placement. Then equalise velocities to hear what the accents contributed. MIDI sounds depend on the instrument used for playback.

What changes and what stays

B alternates hi-hat MIDI velocities of 97 and 56, delays offbeat eighth notes by about 9 ms and snare hits by about 12 ms. A uses hi-hat velocity 81. Both retain the same kick, snare and hi-hat hits, last four bars and have approximately matched integrated loudness. MIDI uses channel 10 and 480 ticks per quarter note, so offsets are rounded to ticks. These are settings for this pattern, not a groove recipe.

HertzKit material under CC0. Provenance, settings and permission · TXT

Humanizing does not mean hiding how a track was made or randomly moving every note. A performance combines intention, repetition and variation; it can also be very regular. Listen to the pattern in the arrangement and choose one issue: flat accents, overlong notes or an unconvincing kick-and-bass relationship.

Pull it off the exact grid

Keep a copy. Try a small timing shift on one voice, repeat it and compare with the base at the same tempo. Its effect depends on pulse and arrangement: no universal millisecond range makes every track natural. Check the setting if notes meant to sound together become separated.

Test the snare, kick and bass relationship

A slightly delayed snare can change a pattern’s feel, but does not always help. Compare aligned and shifted versions while listening to kick, bass and melody too. Use your copy to return to the original rather than turning a stylistic example into a rule for every genre.

Vary the notes' velocity

Use MIDI velocity to shape accents and supporting notes. Try an intentional contrast first and small variation afterwards if needed. There is no requirement to accent beats 1 and 3 or one correct percentage. An instrument may change loudness, attack or sample with velocity: check through the final sound.

Add a take when it serves the idea

A tambourine, guitar or voice can add another articulation, but does not guarantee a better or more human result. Record your own test, compare attacks and gaps and decide whether it adds something. Keeping an exact programmed base can also be a valid musical choice.

Tools to practice this with

The MIDI groove lab lets you edit hits and velocities and compare three two-bar variants. Keep your hits to explore variation without replacing the pattern. The metronome contrasts swing with straight timing; accenting 2 and 4 is a different task. No proposal is automatically better. In MIDI workshop, adjust the pitch, velocity, start and end of existing notes, then prepare and compare the version. Use your DAW to add or delete notes and check the final instrument sound.

You can continue with hear patterns within an arrangement.